Wednesday, 28 April 2010

The Spirit Level Delusion



Anyone who believes that the age of innocence belongs to the past should read some of the reviews devoted to The Spirit Level: Why more equal societies almost always do better (2009). The basic premise of the book should immediately raise suspicions. It is nothing short of a theory of everything, which finds a single factor responsible for almost every health and social problem in the Western world.

The natural response to someone who claims to have suddenly found a grand unifying theory of life is—or should be—profound scepticism. On this occasion, however, many readers and reviewers suspended disbelief (but not all of them). In some circles, the findings of The Spirit Level have become the conventional wisdom.

The reasons for this are two-fold. Firstly, the book appeared under the halo of science (statistics, in reality). Secondly, the theory of everything revolved around income inequality, and so appealed to many on the Left of politics. Put simply, the argument is that 'more equal' countries (principally the Scandinavian states) do better under almost any criteria you can think of than 'less equal' countries (principally the USA, UK and Portugal). The evidence for this is shown on a series of scatter graphs which are—prepare for an understatement—not always totally reliable (for an example, click here).

I hold no brief for extending inequality—I happen to be in the bottom 10% of earners myself—but if the argument for bigger government and higher taxes is to be made, it shouldn't be made on the junk economics and voodoo science of The Spirit Level.

Regular readers will know that I am interested in the misuse of statistics. That is what first attracted me to The Spirit Level. My new book—The Spirit Level Delusion: Fact-checking the Left's new theory of everything—tries to shine the light of reason onto some of the wilder claims made by the Left in the last decade, not just in The Spirit Level but in such books as Affluenza, Happiness, All Consuming and The Selfish Capitalist

So if you've ever heard that Cubans live longer than Americans, that Oscar winners live longer than other actors, that capitalism leads to mental illness, or that income inequality is the root of all evil, I hope you'll buy a copy. It will be available from the usual retailers (Amazon, Tower, Barnes & Noble etc.) shortly. I also have a limited number of copies here if anyone would like one a bit sooner. Postage and packing is free and overseas orders will be sent by air-mail.







UK and Europe (£)











North America (US$)







Solution Graphics








The Spirit Level Delusion:Fact-checking the Left's new theory of everything

by Christopher Snowdon (with a foreword by Patrick Basham)

Democracy Institute/Little Dice - published May 17 2010




4 comments:

RDP said...

Slightly OT (apologies)

Chris and readers,

The antismoking assault over just the last few weeks in Australia

Individual councils to be approached to ban smoking outdoors
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/news/victoria/health-organisations-push-to-ban-smoking-outdoors/story-e6frf7kx-1225856592635
Ms Sharkie: “We also don’t want children to see people smoking and being influenced by that.” (Smokers as corrupters of children - straight from the Godber Blueprint)

Cigarettes to be sold in plain, unappealing packaging
http://www.theage.com.au/lifestyle/wellbeing/rudd-hits-smokers-big-tobacco-20100428-tshr.html

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/news/federal-government-to-make-plain-packaging-compulsory-on-cigarette-packs/story-e6frf7jo-1225859576545

$20 a pack to pay for general health reform (i.e., extortion)
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/news/cigarettes-to-rise-by-650-a-packet-as-part-of-sweeping-tax-reforms/story-e6frf7jo-1225859066340

As usual, there is NO – none whatsoever – coherent questioning of any of this conduct. All those within the closed propaganda-loop, whether ‘experts’ or celebrities, fully endorse the measures. Australia, amongst many others, is indeed a dangerously dumbed-down nation.
Every time the claim is made that the Children™ should be Saved® from smoking, what is actually being stated is:
Regardless of anything else about a smoker, that they smoke, and only that they smoke, makes them an ‘inferior’, detestable, depraved person. The antismoking world wants no more such ‘inferior’ persons. All measures must be taken to prevent such ‘inferior’ persons from occurring. It is the toxic language of bigotry, snobbery, and tyranny.

Ann W. said...

RDP, the same thing is happening in Canada.

"Fletcher said the rationale for banning smoking at playgrounds or athletic fields is the same: Kids often use the facilities and shouldn't be exposed to second-hand smoke or smoking behaviour that they may try to mimic."
http://www.torontosun.com/news/torontoandgta/2010/04/27/13740256.html

"Cigarette Packaging an Advertising Loophole for Tobacco Companies"
http://www.newswire.ca/en/releases/archive/November2009/02/c4870.html

"Ontario suing tobacco companies for $50B"
http://www.theprovince.com/life/Ontario+suing+tobacco+companies/2046821/story.html

"Illegal smokes hit all-time high: group"
http://www.theglobeandmail.com/life/health/illegal-smokes-hit-all-time-high-group/article1528818/

John said...

Chris, The PayPal link doesn't seem to work, loved Velvet Glove and looking forward to reading this one.

Snowdon said...

John,

It should work now. Let me know if not.

Thanks,

Chris